Tubing mascara is a type of mascara that creates small “tubes” around each eyelash, and it is marketed for longer wear and easier removal. As with all cosmetics, there are also caveats to consider.
With the ever-increasing number of makeup and cosmetic products available on the market, it can be confusing to know which options are best. This is especially true of mascara, which comes in a variety of different types and formulas.
Tubing mascara is a newer product that has received increased attention in recent years. This is mostly for good reasons. Tubing mascara is said to last longer and is not difficult to remove like regular waterproof mascaras.
Still, there are some downsides to consider with any form of eye makeup, including tubing mascara.
Before buying tubing mascara, consider how it works, what differentiates it from regular mascara, and what to do if you notice any side effects after use.
True to its name, tubing mascara creates small “tubes” around your eyelashes. This is designed to create a more defined look without the risk of smudging.
The tube-like effects of tubing mascara are made possible thanks to the addition of certain ingredients that are not available in regular mascara. At the same time though, tubing mascara does not create a volumizing appearance as some traditional formulas might.
Here are the key pros and cons for each type of mascara to consider:
Pros of tubing mascara
Tubing mascara contains some of the same ingredients as regular formulas with the exception of a key ingredient responsible for creating tube effects around your lashes. This is done via polymers. These polymers are responsible for encasing each lash with the formula.
While studies are lacking about tubing mascara specifically, there has been some
Additionally, tubing mascara is said to last longer throughout the day than regular formulas, and it’s easier to take off at the end of the day despite its natural waterproof qualities.
Cons of tubing mascara
When using tubing mascara, you will inevitably forego some of the key features of regular mascara, especially volumizing formulas. In theory, tubing mascara might make your lashes look longer and more defined, but this type is not capable of creating a feathering effect.
Another possible downside is the tubing effect the mascara is known for. While some people like the effect, others might think it is too unnatural or clumpy looking. It can also feel quite different until you’re used to the product.
Pros of regular mascara
Compared with tubing mascara, regular formulas have the advantage of buildability. This allows you to paint on multiple coats to create more color, volume, and length, depending on the exact formula you select.
With these features in mind, regular mascara could arguably offer more dramatic looks and be considered your go-to for special events.
Cons of regular mascara
Regular mascara is also notorious for smudging. While you can use a waterproof formula, these are not entirely immune to running by the end of the day.
All types of regular mascara are harder to remove than tubular versions. You will need to use eye makeup remover or petroleum jelly (Vaseline). Chemical formulas or excessive rubbing from trying to take the product off can also cause irritation.
While there’s a lack of clinical research behind tubing mascara, there are numerous anecdotal benefits. First, the way the product wraps around your eyelashes could mean less product is used during each application.
The tubing effect and ingredients also help tubing mascara formulas stay in place despite contact with skin oils or sweating. This can be a great benefit for people with naturally oily skin, or for those who try to fit in quick mid-day workouts.
In theory, you may also be able to wear tubing mascara all day without worrying about the risk of the product running if you encounter humidity.
Despite its long-wear, another purported benefit of using tubing mascara is its ease of removal. You can typically use water and a soft cloth or cotton ball to remove the tubes around your lashes at the end of the day.
This means less rubbing and a reduced reliance on chemical-based eye makeup removers that can sometimes irritate sensitive skin.
Just as there is a lack of data about tubing mascaras, more specifically, it’s important to know there are not many studies looking into their potential risks either.
When assessing the potential risks of using tubing mascara, it may be best to approach these products in a similar way to your assessment of new cosmetics in general.
In particular, mascaras are prone to microbial growth, and tubing mascaras are no exception. As a rule of thumb, experts recommend replacing your mascara product every 3 months to help prevent harmful microorganisms from impacting your eyes.
If you typically use an eyelash separating comb after mascara, you should avoid this step with tubing mascara. Not only is it likely unnecessary, but the clumping action of the mascara can make it difficult to run the eyelash comb through your lashes, and possibly lead to eye injuries.
There’s also a possibility of mascara allergy symptoms, which may affect your eyes as well as the skin around them. If you develop any rashes or other signs of irritation, discontinue the product immediately and consider talking with a doctor.
As its name indicates, tubing mascara is designed to create tubes around your eyelashes to offer more definition. On top of this, tubing mascara is thought to last longer throughout the day, and you may be able to remove it easily with water.
Still, tubing mascara isn’t for everyone, as it can take getting used to the way the eyelash tubes look and feel. Like other types of eye makeup, you should look for reputable brands and discontinue using tubing mascara if you develop any irritation or infections.
Due to the pros and cons of both tubing and regular mascaras, you might want to have both in your makeup drawer, if your budget allows.